Hello! This is my first Challenge - I heard Dr. Coco on Growcast talking about the New Year's and 420 Challenges, but life circumstances and timing got in the way. But this time I'm ready and excited to hone my mainline technique with a bunch of other growers! I started growing last July and it has quickly taken over my life, in the best way. Although I started in soil, and I have kept some soil plants due to how fascinated I am with the soil life, I've become increasingly convinced that hydro is the best fit for my circumstances and desires, after a couple of successful DWC cycles. I haven't actually tried coco/HP yet :p but probably will in the future.
For the PTGC, I am growing and following a single Big Bud plant (breeder unknown as it was a gift), growing in water culture with GH Flora Trio. I run a small perpetual harvest system, so I will just use one individual for the challenge journal.
I also want to attempt the Party Cup Challenge, but haven't settled on which strain or strains to attempt it with.
Edit 19 Aug: I settled on "The White OG" for the Party Cup Challenge, it's a cross between two other OG Kush spinoffs. Mainly selected because I have more of them than any other seeds, and because they have a relatively short flowering period and compact habit. I'm going to try two (maybe three) different techniques for the PCC: a mini Kratky raft (but with more refills!) and a "duoponic" nested-cup technique. And if necessary I'll add a mini airstone to the cup. 🙂
Happy growing!
16 days in, growth is starting to pick up appreciably. These pictures were taken roughly 14 hours apart (last night and within the hour, respectively), and root development is starting to take off. I moved the other plant that was in here (the Jack Herer) to the flower room, giving her more light and space. I can't wait to see what she looks like in a few weeks, but I may have to flip her early, or only top twice, just to have enough room to flower her! We will see...
16 days in, growth is starting to pick up appreciably. These pictures were taken roughly 14 hours apart (last night and within the hour, respectively), and root development is starting to take off. I moved the other plant that was in here (the Jack Herer) to the flower room, giving her more light and space. I can't wait to see what she looks like in a few weeks, but I may have to flip her early, or only top twice, just to have enough room to flower her! We will see.../
This pic is from last night.
Sorry, I'm still figuring out how to attach pics properly. Here are the ones from today!
And as a bonus (cuz I'm not sure the best way to start another grow journal given my perpetual harvest setup), here is a pic of my flower room! Clockwise from right: Special Queen #1 (Royal Queen Seeds), Jack Herer (Seedsman), Girl Scout Crack (Seedsman).
Roots are really starting to take off today, we have five main roots visible and branching starting. I'm going to cut the bottom of the net pot to give the taproot some extra room as I have learnt from past plants.
I'm also soaking 4 The White OG (Seedsman) seeds for the Party Cup Challenge!
1
There's nothing like opening the tent in the morning to see obvious growth! Leaves have unfurled to just barely less than the width of the container, 7cm x 5 cm tall, and roots are starting to explode. I added some new, slightly stronger nutrient broth today, too, since it's looking a little pale and has been in the germination-strength broth for almost 3 weeks.
Last night I screwed up and dropped a seedling tray that contained the Peyote Gorilla and the White OG seeds for the Party Girls. They all fell out onto the floor and got mixed up. :-/ I started the Peyote Gorilla two days earlier (along with a single Blueberry (kept separate), and one seedling among them is starting to sprout, hopefully that means it is the PG and the rest are the White OG, but I guess time will tell (hopefully). That Blueberry seed I had in paper towels dried out yesterday! But I wet it again and put it in a baggie to stay moist, and luckily this morning it had a nice 2 cm radicle poking out. I rolled it in some Great White and put it into a Root Riot cube and into the tray.
By lights out, the Big Bud had started to droop a little bit, but I am hoping that is just its circadian rhythm and it getting sleepy.
25 days in, and our lovely contestant may be facing some issues, but I'm not entirely sure. Yesterday I noticed bronze patches on her first (1-finger) and to a lesser degree second set of true leaves. Today the first set are quite yellow but mottled with ugly, livid splotches. The second pair have slightly more noticeable spots (towards distal edges/'fingertips'.) The first set's yellowing is expected, if perhaps a bit early. But the hint of progression worries me. There is also a possibility of infection; yesterday I removed a small clump of dust or other matter from the roots, and today there is some matting starting and perhaps discoloration. It doesn't look too bad, but my young DWC operation has a history of root rot and with the perpetual harvest system I haven't got my cleaning/disinfecting schedule dialed in yet. pH and EC are in acceptable range (~6.1, 1.0 respectively). The water temps are also on the high end of acceptable, at 70° F (21° C) ± 1° . I already use Hydroguard, and have now added a small amount of Rapidstart (magical chemicals?) and Armour Si (silica) on top of the Flora Trio base nutrients. I am generally skeptical of supplements, since the Flora Trio is supposed to provide all needed nutrients and has been formulated to do so. However, enough people had enough good to say about these, for root growth and disease resistance, and they're not very expensive, that it seemed worth a shot to protect my roots. Incidentally, one of the reasons I am so excited about the Party Cup Challenge is the prospect of an ultra-compact hydro system to run multiple plants side by side to do my own experiments in the future. 🙂
Now for the Party Girls! These are what I'm truly excited about.
I spent the weekend watching videos about the Kratky, two-cup "duoponic", and plastic-cup 'smart pot' techniques. Some of these were rather impressive, especially peppers in the two-cups. On the top row are the Kratky Kups. I started off using wooden kebab skewers to hold them above the waterline, but pretty white fungal hyphae started to coat them basically immediately so I swapped them out for wire 'spiderwebs'. The seedlings are starting to grow well, and today I saw that my Special Queen cuttings finally started to root, so I put them in cups like that too.
The 'two cup seed starting method' involves starting seeds in Solo cups with holes in the bottom. When roots start coming out the bottom you put the cup in a second cup with nutrient solution in the bottom. Thus the plant can grow much larger than if it was just root-bound in the cup. Now, this clearly violates contest rules by having the roots come out of the cup. So I made one 'traditional' one which disqualification is an accepted given, and a second one with an old 4-oz yoghurt cup, which will then sit in the solo cup and thus all be contained within it.
Finally I punctured a solo cup all over with a hot awl, making a "smart pot" which will hopefully allow for more airflow. I suppose I should have done this with all the soil cups, but had enough to keep track of as is.
I hope some version of Kratky works for babies, it would be great if I could easily start my seedlings/clones in solo cups and then put in a real DWC tank for flowering. My seedling tent is only 2x2x4' so it would be awfully convenient. I would also love a little hydroponic windowsill herb garden (as in basil, rosemary, etc) in the kitchen or study! This whole Solo Cup thing has really got my gears turning, @dr-coco this is an excellent theme,thank you. just wanted to share my appreciation. <3
Our lovely primary contestant, No. 3.2 Big Bud, has developed root rot, I think I had the water level too high and started to drown the roots. On Sunday I pulled off the badly infected material (all the roots in the bucket) which sloughed off depressingly easily. Then a scrubbing and dunk in disinfectant for the container and hose, a new air stone, and a water change were in order, and on Monday (yesterday) removed the horribly yellow, spotted, and twisted leaves. The roots seem longer today but there is an odd rusty colouration to the veins on one of the surviving leaves that is worrisome.
To make matters worse the Party Girls have almost all hit their own slumps. The seedlings that were intended to be passive hydro/Kratky look twisted and sad. The clones are yellowed and pathetic looking. My suspicion is that this problem is from:
A) not knowing the right water level to put at first, for before roots start to dip into the water, so they are either soaking all the time (bad) or the delicate rootlets dry out (bad) and
B) not covering the containers. I tried using cut up black trash bags but it was too hard to work with so I just left them open, figuring I could just keep topping off the water and that I would be replacing it too often for algae or bugs to form. I think this is causing the air surrounding the roots to be too dry and so when they try to reach for the water they are burnt off, due to the ambient air burning the roots, in a bad version of the same mechanism responsible for the popularity of grow bags for soil/coco.
Happily I found a roll of black vinyl in the trash outside my house so I am going to make covers for the plants to replace the coasters I put as an emergency stopgap. I am hoping that this will allow them to recover and grow. I will probably just toss the sickly clones as it's too much of a pain in the arse nursing all these solo cups for sick clones.
And possibly also
C) the lights are too bright: the tent is too short to move them away any further so I put clear cups over the smallest ones to shield them. This is probably especially the problem for the clones.
So my plan of action is:
For the largest plant, with the root rot, I bought some new 1 gallon containers which I'll move that one to so I can run its current container through the dishwasher, and make sure everything is squeaky clean before another full water change.
I'll also mix up some new seedling strength nutrient water and change that again, before topping off all the cups with new vinyl covers.
Our lovely primary contestant, No. 3.2 Big Bud, has developed root rot, I think I had the water level too high and started to drown the roots. On Sunday I pulled off the badly infected material (all the roots in the bucket) which sloughed off depressingly easily. Then a scrubbing and dunk in disinfectant for the container and hose, a new air stone, and a water change were in order, and on Monday (yesterday) removed the horribly yellow, spotted, and twisted leaves. The roots seem longer today but there is an odd rusty colouration to the veins on one of the surviving leaves that is worrisome.
To make matters worse the Party Girls have almost all hit their own slumps. The seedlings that were intended to be passive hydro/Kratky look twisted and sad. The clones are yellowed and pathetic looking. My suspicion is that this problem is from:
A) not knowing the right water level to put at first, for before roots start to dip into the water, so they are either soaking all the time (bad) or the delicate rootlets dry out (bad) and
B) not covering the containers. I tried using cut up black trash bags but it was too hard to work with so I just left them open, figuring I could just keep topping off the water and that I would be replacing it too often for algae or bugs to form. I think this is causing the air surrounding the roots to be too dry and so when they try to reach for the water they are burnt off, due to the ambient air burning the roots, in a bad version of the same mechanism responsible for the popularity of grow bags for soil/coco.
Happily I found a roll of black vinyl in the trash outside my house so I am going to make covers for the plants to replace the coasters I put as an emergency stopgap. I am hoping that this will allow them to recover and grow. I will probably just toss the sickly clones as it's too much of a pain in the arse nursing all these solo cups for sick clones.
And possibly also
C) the lights are too bright: the tent is too short to move them away any further so I put clear cups over the smallest ones to shield them. This is probably especially the problem for the clones.
So my plan of action is:
For the largest plant, with the root rot, I bought some new 1 gallon containers which I'll move that one to so I can run its current container through the dishwasher, and make sure everything is squeaky clean before another full water change.
I'll also mix up some new seedling strength nutrient water and change that again, before topping off all the cups with new vinyl covers.
Some bonus content, for (my own) morale purposes:
These soil plants were horribly sickened by organic liquid nutrients (yes, bad idea) which had gone off and which pH had radically dropped. I flushed them, fed them some normal GH Flora to help with the terrible deficiency symptoms they'd been showing (hence giving them the nutes which turned out to be rancid in the first place) and kept watering them, figuring whenever my hydro seedlings started to need more space I'd chop them down and harvest whatever I could off them. Surprisingly over the last week they've started to look, and smell, a lot better, and I'm actually looking forward to smoking these. The one with the small round buds is Girl Scout Crack, the larger one on the right is Special Queen #1 from RQS, a plant which I love for its ease of cloning, rapid growth, hardy nature, and exceptional smoke. Even in these terrible conditions she has started making big, smelly, pretty flowers.
The happy green plants are my hydro flower room, and a look at these two rooms explains why I've been transitioning to hydro, next year I would like to try a couple of autos in my back garden, but as far as my indoor gardening goes, I think I will stick to hydroponics, if I change anything it will most likely be switching to coco instead of DWC to save power and not have to worry so much about blackouts. The biggest plant (the right half of the tent) is another SQ#1 in happier conditions. Her roots are starting to look a bit unhealthy (clumping instead of spreading out, brownish instead of white/cream) but she only has another week or 2 to go so I'm not too worried about it.
The pipe with nice dried bud is another success, this was "Cream and Cheese 1:1" from Seedsman, supposedly 22% THC and 18% CBD. That was my first unambiguously successful grow and yielded 8 oz dry flower. I am but a lowly home gardener and did not send away for a tissue test, though I would like to in the future; but based on its effects I'd guess that's reasonably accurate. It's really wonderful stuff and I hope to see more high-octane 1:1 strains in the future, I love it and so have my human-guinea-pig friends.
@furrysparkle @gringogrow Thank you all for your advice, sorry I awoled for a while and didn't get back, it's been kind of a crappy week.
Nutrients and Lockout: I replaced all the nutrients but I am worried that I'm not doing it right despite looking at tutorials. Specifically 1) the order in which to add nutrients and supplements (especially liquid Silicate) to avoid precipitation or lockout, and 2) how to adjust to the right EC. I had just been using GH Flora Trio and Hydroguard but started using their RapidStart and Armour Si supplements and worried I am doing it wrong or that I just have too much stuff in it.
Originally what I was doing is: 1) Fill the bucket to the level desired, eg 2 gallons. 2) Add nutrients, Micro/Grow/Bloom in that order, stirring between. 3) add supplements in the same fashion. I've seen some people say add silica before anything else, other people say at the end, and the bottle says nothing either way. 4) check EC, if it's too high slosh off some water and add fresh water. When that's about right, 5) adjust pH.
But then reading about it more what I read was instead you're just supposed to add 1/2 -1 gal water to the bottom of the container to prevent nutrient lockout, add the amount of nutrients that's supposed to be in the final volume (like if it says 5 mL per gallon, add 10 mL since we want 2 gallons) then add water until the desired EC is reached, then finally adjust pH. If anyone can tell me what's what I'd greatly appreciate it!!
(ETA:) My other question is about nutrient PPM/EC, hopefully I can express it clearly enough.
3) If I am just using the base nutrients, using x amount per gallon and then adjust the PPM/EC down to not hurt the plants, for example to 1.2 EC. But if I wanted to use a supplement/s, I adjust the EC down to the same level, right? Does this mean that using too many supplements (eg Hydroguard AND Rapidstart AND ArmourSi, the plant is therefore not getting enough of its base nutrients? I hope that makes sense. I don't want to be using too many different products either but the Hydroguard and RapidStart seem to help a lot with my root vigor and I really wanted to try the Si for stronger limbs and disease resistance. But if I'm using all three does that mean that my plant is not getting the nutrition that it needs, assuming the EC is low enough that it's not being burnt?
4) WRT container size: I started using the 1 gallon containers just for seedlings so that I could fit more into the tiny 2x2x4' tent I'm using for them. When they get big enough to start drinking appreciably I move them to 3 gallon buckets. My thinking was that in soil(less) we start them in smaller containers and work up to the full size pots, and so they would probably be okay in the 1 gallon ones to start. Is this wrong for hydroponics? I don't really have much soil experience either so thank you for explaining.
I started out with 5 gallon buckets, but I am disabled and was not able to handle them safely. So I switched to 3 gallon buckets which I put 2 gallons of water in. I haven't noticed too much of a swing in pH, maybe because I change the water so often (usually every 3-5 days when they're bigger)? Or have just been lucky so far. I do check the water quality every 1-2 days and adjust pH down as needed. The only obvious issue with the 3 gallon buckets so far, is that when the plants are mature they drink rapidly and I have to completely change the nutrients every three days or so and check the water level and pH daily. However I am stuck at home all day (even before the plague) and so that's not a problem for me. I have also started flowering them younger so they don't get so big, we will see how that affects things. However I will keep that in mind for future plants -- and maybe start them off in their full size containers?
Thank you all so much for your help and suggestions, it is a big help! <3
The seedling tent is pretty sad on the hydro side, I ordered a larger container to drill holes in for one communal tank that won't suck so bad to try to monitor. But the Partiers look pretty good, other than that one sickly seedling that's actually 2 weeks younger than the rest, not just horrifically stunted. It does look pretty sad, but not THAT sad. But the soil seedlings look pretty good actually, and the largest one under the vinyl is in a yoghurt cup inside of the Solo cup, where it will receive nutrients through the roots coming out of the bottom, enabling it hopefully to get through its lifespan without leaving the bounds of the outer Solo cup. I'm not sure whether to immediately put it in the flower room or lert it go a little more and would appreciate your further insight 🙂 Will put another pic of the two fucked up but interesting and harvestable soil plants, and what the communal seedling tank looks like when it happens. Thanks for all your help and input.
It's not all bad though, the outdoor plant and her indoor twin (albeit not on the same flowering schedule!) look pretty damn good to me. A little rough around the edge of the leaves indoors, but we're more than a week past the '8 weeks' it supposedly is supposed to flower for, and I want to push that further this time than with t he earlier clones, which lived indoors and flowered 65
days.
PS that's a sweet potato slip
More good stuff -- I got a Magic Flight box vape thing and bottle-bong attachment thing. I love the design and it works well after some getting used to. There's a little tray for concentrates which I haven't tried yet.
And that's some more recent close ups of the indoor SQ#1 . It smells so good I can't wait to harvest....but I'm going to wait at least another week, maybe 2.
More good stuff -- I got a Magic Flight box vape thing and bottle-bong attachment thing. I love the design and it works well after some getting used to. There's a little tray for concentrates which I haven't tried yet.
And that's some more recent close ups of the indoor SQ#1 . It smells so good I can't wait to harvest....but I'm going to wait at least another week, maybe 2.
Hi y'all, sorry for disappearing. It was a very eventful past few weeks.
I tried to make a communal seedling bucket like some of you recommended, but an infection took over quickly and I lost some of the babies. But those lost did NOT include the original Big Bud plant! But instead of being a Mainlined Hydro plant, it is now a Non-Topper Soil plant. 😜
I transplanted it to my homemade potting media as a 'Hail Mary' maneuver following root problems and general mismanagement of the DWC seedling area, and it worked! So although it hasn't undergone any topping, it did start growing again quickly again after a week in the soil. Yesterday I moved it up to a 5 gallon and it is ready to flip today!!!
In the Solo Cups, the Party Girls are doing pretty well in their 'duoponic' setup, too! I'd like to dial this technique in to use to make small plants in my mini tent for pollen/seeds, when I start messing around with breeding as I plan to in the future, and for fun, also try growing peppers and salad greens like this during the winter, as I've seen people do on YouTube, without sacrificing much of my grow space.
I also bought today a bag of what's supposed to be pre-mixed and prepared coco grow media. I have a brick of coco and some perlite, but for my first coco grow it seemed worth the extra few bucks not to have to deal with so much mess and work in my apartment. The guy at the store said to run CalMag water through it before use, but I'll read up on it before trying. As much as I like the DWC I've had recurrent root problems and coco seems easier to manage in some ways, plus air pumps and AC won't be so much of a problem as they've been, my neighbors don't love the noise and coco will let me be quieter.

